
Overall: 6.0/10 by 2 dudes
Dudes: 6.0/10
Trend: 6.0/10 over past 5 reviews 
Style: Scottish Heavy Ale
ABV: 8.50%
Seasonal: Year Round
50%
Add a Beer Review or Add a Short Beer Review
Date tasted: September 04, 2009
Color: Dark Brown
Aroma: 8 (25%)
Taste: 8 (25%)
Look: 8 (15%)
Drinkability: 8 (35%)
Overall: 8.0
| Beer | Rating |
|---|---|
| AleSmith Wee Heavy | 8.0 |
| Backwoods Bastard | 9.5 |
| Black Scotch Ale | 7.0 |
| Highway 78 Scotch Ale | 9.1 |
| Louie's Reserve Scotch Ale | 8.0 |
| Odell 90 Shilling | 8.3 |
Not much head. Aroma has a hint of Scotch. Seems to have too simple of taste and the high alcohol comes out without a balance of flavors. Similar to drinking an average scotch - just not that interesting.
Date tasted: April 24, 2009
Color: Reddish Brown
Aroma: 4 (25%)
Taste: 4 (25%)
Look: 4 (15%)
Drinkability: 4 (35%)
Overall: 4.0
rich hasn't reviewed enough!
$1.69, 2 servings, 12 oz. bottles
9.4
9.1
9.0
9.0
8.9
8.7
8.3
8.2
Pours with two fingers of tan foam into my favorite mason mug. Some retention with some lacing.
Aroma has some big malt: caramel and grain with slight hint of smoke. I might even detect some alcohol.
Taste begins caramel malt transitioning to brown sugar and more malt, ending with molasses, some smoke with a dried fruit, malty aftertaste. Interesting and huge malt.
Heavy mouth feel with medium carbonation that mixes with the complexity to make a very drinkable beer.
Lots of malt with many hidden treasures for the senses. Really good relaxing beer. Savor two or three rather than guzzling them, the alcohol will catch up with you any way. Enjoy!