Two regular dudes who happen to be huge fans of American craft beer.

Barfly - Barley Island Brewing Company

Barfly

Overall: 8.4/10 by 3 dudes

Dudes: 8.5/10

Trend: 8.4/10 over past 5 reviews

Style: American IPA

ABV: 5.60%

IBU: 60

Seasonal: Year Round

Have Another

100%

Add a Beer Review or Add a Short Beer Review



 

8.3

Have Another:


Pours a nice medium amber color that has a hint of orange to it. Nice two inch off white head that thick and foamy. Good retention on the head with thick foamy lacing.

Aroma is very pleasant. I am getting a citrus hop along with a grain or bready aroma. Has an earthiness to it with a hint of floral.

Taste is clean and refreshing. Has a bit of a mellow start that works into a robust citrus floral hop. Has a nice sweetness to it. Finishes with a mild bitterness that lingers on the palate.

Medium body with light to medium carbonation. Sweet and sticky mouth feel.

Overall this is another solid IPA. Well balanced, clean and refreshing. I like it.......try one!

Date tasted: June 26, 2011

Color: Medium Amber

Rating Breakdown

Aroma: 9 (25%)

Taste: 8 (25%)

Look: 8 (15%)

Drinkability: 8 (35%)

Overall: 8.3

Similar Beers Tasted


 
 

8.4

Have Another:


Poured clear into my pint glass. The foam is off-white, about a third of the glass, and thick. Retention is really nice while leaving some very sticky, splotchy lacing throughout.

Aroma is equal parts citrus hops with a bread malt backbone. Slight hints of floral develop. The malt profile is reminiscent of fat tire.

Taste is a little sweeter than I expected based on the nose. A nice floral, citrus hop profile starts almost immediately and lasts through to the finish. A pleasant and not over powering bitterness lasts for a while.

Medium body might be a little generous, but, then again, might easily placed here. Nice carbonation with a sticky mouth.

Being pleasantly surprised by a beer is never a bad thing. Barfly goes above and beyond my expectations by a long shot. Has almost a presence of being much bigger than it is. Enjoy!

Date tasted: June 07, 2010

Color: Amber

Rating Breakdown

Aroma: 8 (25%)

Taste: 9 (25%)

Look: 9 (15%)

Drinkability: 8 (35%)

Overall: 8.4

Similar Beers Tasted


 
 

8.6

Have Another:


A: Great hue of orange-amber, slightly cloudy. Big foamy head, not super sticky, but did stick around.

S: Not as attractive as the taste. A little bready, citrusy.

T: Great zap of citrus and floral. The taste is orange / grapefruit, then muffled malt sweetness, and a subtle hop bite at the end. A medium mouthfeel and carbonation is great.

D: Wasn't expecting much and found I really liked it. Big personality for a "regular" IPA, I've had Imperials that were not as assertive. West Coast hops meets Midwest fruits and in very balanced brew. I'll seek out this brewers other works.

Date tasted: June 05, 2010

Color: Deep Orange Amber

Rating Breakdown

Aroma: 8 (25%)

Taste: 9 (25%)

Look: 8 (15%)

Drinkability: 9 (35%)

Overall: 8.6

Similar Beers Tasted


 

Spread the Word

Cost Breakdown

$1.99, 1 serving, 12 oz. bottles

Highest Rated Similar Beers

Beer Swapping

0 swap ins and 0 swap outs

Hops

Summit