
Overall: 9.4/10 by 1 dude
Dudes: 9.4/10
Trend: 9.4/10 over past 5 reviews 
Style: Spice, Herb, or Vegetable Beer
ABV: 7.50%
Seasonal: One-time
100%
Add a Beer Review or Add a Short Beer Review
Date tasted: August 12, 2010
Color: Black
Aroma: 10 (25%)
Taste: 9 (25%)
Look: 10 (15%)
Drinkability: 9 (35%)
Overall: 9.4
| Beer | Rating |
|---|---|
| Frog’s Hollow Double Pumpkin Ale | 8.0 |
| Harvest Moon Pumpkin Ale | 5.0 |
| Hoptober | 8.0 |
| Ichabod Ale | 6.0 |
| Juju Ginger | 6.0 |
| Key Lime Pie | 7.9 |
$2.49, 1 serving, 12 oz. bottles
9.0
8.9
8.0
8.0
8.0
8.0
8.0
7.9
Poured opaque with a nice looking brown, two finger foam. Retention was outstanding leaving a nice solid covering over my beer. As it receded it also became creamy and thick to the eye. Lacing was thick but not lasting.
Aroma is solid for a porter: roasted, chocolate with a side of smoke and even coffee. Toffee and bread malt add to the complexity. Even a touch of chili character eventually comes through too.
Taste is just a complex and big as the aroma. The foam, as it touches your lips, adds a nice creaminess up front. Sweet caramel and toffee notes meet the tongue first followed by a wave of bread and smoke. The smoke character I would describe as peat and about as perfect a compliment to the beer as can ever be expected. A bit of spice and bitterness into the end and finish. The finish rounds out with some heat: I think from both the alcohol and chilis. It warms, even in the stomach.
This is quite a big beer with a mild carbonation that is accented by the creaminess of the foam.
This is top notch. I don't care for smokey beers but this one did it perfectly, as not to be an annoyance. Big, chewy, and outstanding. I didn't think this was going to win me over so I only bought one. Yeah, one. Egghead. Enjoy!